您的位置: 首页 » 法律资料网 » 法律法规 »

最高人民法院、最高人民检察院关于办理环境污染刑事案件适用法律若干问题的解释

作者:法律资料网 时间:2024-07-22 07:53:36  浏览:9312   来源:法律资料网
下载地址: 点击此处下载

最高人民法院、最高人民检察院关于办理环境污染刑事案件适用法律若干问题的解释

最高人民法院 最高人民检察院


最高人民法院、最高人民检察院关于办理环境污染刑事案件适用法律若干问题的解释



(法释〔2013〕15号,2013年6月8日最高人民法院审判委员会第1581次会议、2013年6月8日最高人民检察院第十二届检察委员会第7次会议通过)




《最高人民法院、最高人民检察院关于办理环境污染刑事案件适用法律若干问题的解释》已于2013年6月8日由最高人民法院审判委员会第1581次会议、2013年6月8日由最高人民检察院第十二届检察委员会第7次会议通过,现予公布,自2013年6月19日起施行。




最高人民法院



最高人民检察院



2013年6月17日








最高人民法院、最高人民检察院关于办理环境污染刑事案件适用法律若干问题的解释



为依法惩治有关环境污染犯罪,根据《中华人民共和国刑法》《中华人民共和国刑事诉讼法》的有关规定,现就办理此类刑事案件适用法律的若干问题解释如下:



第一条 实施刑法第三百三十八条规定的行为,具有下列情形之一的,应当认定为“严重污染环境”:



(一)在饮用水水源一级保护区、自然保护区核心区排放、倾倒、处置有放射性的废物、含传染病病原体的废物、有毒物质的;



(二)非法排放、倾倒、处置危险废物三吨以上的;



(三)非法排放含重金属、持久性有机污染物等严重危害环境、损害人体健康的污染物超过国家污染物排放标准或者省、自治区、直辖市人民政府根据法律授权制定的污染物排放标准三倍以上的;



(四)私设暗管或者利用渗井、渗坑、裂隙、溶洞等排放、倾倒、处置有放射性的废物、含传染病病原体的废物、有毒物质的;



(五)两年内曾因违反国家规定,排放、倾倒、处置有放射性的废物、含传染病病原体的废物、有毒物质受过两次以上行政处罚,又实施前列行为的;



(六)致使乡镇以上集中式饮用水水源取水中断十二小时以上的;



(七)致使基本农田、防护林地、特种用途林地五亩以上,其他农用地十亩以上,其他土地二十亩以上基本功能丧失或者遭受永久性破坏的;



(八)致使森林或者其他林木死亡五十立方米以上,或者幼树死亡二千五百株以上的;



(九)致使公私财产损失三十万元以上的;



(十)致使疏散、转移群众五千人以上的;



(十一)致使三十人以上中毒的;



(十二)致使三人以上轻伤、轻度残疾或者器官组织损伤导致一般功能障碍的;



(十三)致使一人以上重伤、中度残疾或者器官组织损伤导致严重功能障碍的;



(十四)其他严重污染环境的情形。



第二条 实施刑法第三百三十九条、第四百零八条规定的行为,具有本解释第一条第六项至第十三项规定情形之一的,应当认定为“致使公私财产遭受重大损失或者严重危害人体健康”或者“致使公私财产遭受重大损失或者造成人身伤亡的严重后果”。



第三条 实施刑法第三百三十八条、第三百三十九条规定的行为,具有下列情形之一的,应当认定为“后果特别严重”:



(一)致使县级以上城区集中式饮用水水源取水中断十二个小时以上的;



(二)致使基本农田、防护林地、特种用途林地十五亩以上,其他农用地三十亩以上,其他土地六十亩以上基本功能丧失或者遭受永久性破坏的;



(三)致使森林或者其他林木死亡一百五十立方米以上,或者幼树死亡七千五百株以上的;



(四)致使公私财产损失一百万元以上的;



(五)致使疏散、转移群众一万五千人以上的;



(六)致使一百人以上中毒的;



(七)致使十人以上轻伤、轻度残疾或者器官组织损伤导致一般功能障碍的;



(八)致使三人以上重伤、中度残疾或者器官组织损伤导致严重功能障碍的;



(九)致使一人以上重伤、中度残疾或者器官组织损伤导致严重功能障碍,并致使五人以上轻伤、轻度残疾或者器官组织损伤导致一般功能障碍的;



(十)致使一人以上死亡或者重度残疾的;



(十一)其他后果特别严重的情形。



第四条 实施刑法第三百三十八条、第三百三十九条规定的犯罪行为,具有下列情形之一的,应当酌情从重处罚:



(一)阻挠环境监督检查或者突发环境事件调查的;



(二)闲置、拆除污染防治设施或者使污染防治设施不正常运行的;



(三)在医院、学校、居民区等人口集中地区及其附近,违反国家规定排放、倾倒、处置有放射性的废物、含传染病病原体的废物、有毒物质或者其他有害物质的;



(四)在限期整改期间,违反国家规定排放、倾倒、处置有放射性的废物、含传染病病原体的废物、有毒物质或者其他有害物质的。



实施前款第一项规定的行为,构成妨害公务罪的,以污染环境罪与妨害公务罪数罪并罚。



第五条 实施刑法第三百三十八条、第三百三十九条规定的犯罪行为,但及时采取措施,防止损失扩大、消除污染,积极赔偿损失的,可以酌情从宽处罚。



第六条 单位犯刑法第三百三十八条、第三百三十九条规定之罪的,依照本解释规定的相应个人犯罪的定罪量刑标准,对直接负责的主管人员和其他直接责任人员定罪处罚,并对单位判处罚金。



第七条 行为人明知他人无经营许可证或者超出经营许可范围,向其提供或者委托其收集、贮存、利用、处置危险废物,严重污染环境的,以污染环境罪的共同犯罪论处。



第八条 违反国家规定,排放、倾倒、处置含有毒害性、放射性、传染病病原体等物质的污染物,同时构成污染环境罪、非法处置进口的固体废物罪、投放危险物质罪等犯罪的,依照处罚较重的犯罪定罪处罚。



第九条 本解释所称“公私财产损失”,包括污染环境行为直接造成财产损毁、减少的实际价值,以及为防止污染扩大、消除污染而采取必要合理措施所产生的费用。



第十条 下列物质应当认定为“有毒物质”:



(一)危险废物,包括列入国家危险废物名录的废物,以及根据国家规定的危险废物鉴别标准和鉴别方法认定的具有危险特性的废物;



(二)剧毒化学品、列入重点环境管理危险化学品名录的化学品,以及含有上述化学品的物质;



(三)含有铅、汞、镉、铬等重金属的物质;



(四)《关于持久性有机污染物的斯德哥尔摩公约》附件所列物质;



(五)其他具有毒性,可能污染环境的物质。



第十一条 对案件所涉的环境污染专门性问题难以确定的,由司法鉴定机构出具鉴定意见,或者由国务院环境保护部门指定的机构出具检验报告。



县级以上环境保护部门及其所属监测机构出具的监测数据,经省级以上环境保护部门认可的,可以作为证据使用。



第十二条 本解释发布实施后,《最高人民法院关于审理环境污染刑事案件具体应用法律若干问题的解释》(法释〔2006〕4号)同时废止;之前发布的司法解释和规范性文件与本解释不一致的,以本解释为准。



附表下载

http://file.chinacourt.org/f.php?id=534&class=file





下载地址: 点击此处下载

关于进一步加强对税务学会的管理和业务指导的通知

国家税务总局 民政部


关于进一步加强对税务学会的管理和业务指导的通知
国家税务总局、民政部



中国税务学会,各省、自治区、直辖市和计划单列市民政厅(局)、国家税务局、地方税务局、税务学会:
关于国家税务局、地方税务局两套税务机构分设后,各地税务学会的设置和业务主管问题,经研究,现提出如下意见:
一、中国税务学会是研究税收科学的群众性学术团体。在省及省以下税务机构分设为国家税务局、地方税务局后,税收理论体系上仍是一个整体。根据国务院发布的《社会团体登记管理条例》第十六条“在同一行政区域内不得重复成立相同或者相似的社会团体”的规定,地方性税务学
会作为社会法人团体只能是一个,不得因税务机构分设而在同一行政区域内重复设立两个税务学会。
二、为使地方税务学会具有代表性,在其领导成员中,应当既有国税局的代表,又有地税局的代表参加。国税局和地税局的领导都应关心、支持学会工作。税务学会要在新形势下,更好地发挥它的作用,努力为整个税收事业的发展服务。
三、关于各地税务学会的业务主管问题。考虑到税务学会的建立和发展已有十几年的历史,在组织管理上已有良好基础,为了保证学会活动的连续性,宜以国家税务局为其业务主管部门。望各地民政厅(局)、国税局、地税局都要加强对税务学会的监督管理和业务指导。
以上各点请各地研究贯彻执行。



1995年8月7日

MERCHANT SHIPPING (PREVENTION AND CONTROL OF POLLUTION) ORDINANCE ——附加英文版

Hong Kong


MERCHANT SHIPPING (PREVENTION AND CONTROL OF POLLUTION) ORDINANCE
 (CHAPTER 413)
 ARRANGEMENT OF SECTIONS
  
  ion
  
  I    PRELIMINARY
  hort title
  nterpretation
  
  II    REGULATIONS FOR THE PREVENTION AND CONTROL OF POLLUTION
  egulations for the prevention and control of pollution
  enalty for taking detained ship to sea
  
  III   SHIPPING CASUALTIES INVOLVING A RISK OF POLLUTION
  pplication of Part III
  hipping casualties
  irections; right to recover in respect of unreasonable loss or
damage
  ffences in relation to section 6
  ervice of directions under section 6
  Enforcement of fines
  Saving of rights of action, etc.
  
  IV    SAVINGS, AMENDMENTS AND REPEALS
  Savings, amendments and repeals
  
  dule. (Omitted)
  
  rdinance to provide for the prevention and control of pollution 
from
  s and for incidental or related matters.
  January 1991] L. N. 14 of 1991
 PART I PRELIMINARY
  
  hort title
  Ordinance may be cited as the Merchant Shipping 
(Prevention and
  rol of Pollution) Ordinance.
  nterpretation
  his Ordinance, unless the context otherwise requires--
  trol" includes contain and reduce;
  ector" means the Director of Marine;
  charge" means any release, howsoever caused, from a ship and 
includes
  escape, disposal, spilling, leaking, pumping, emitting or 
emptying;
  does not include--
  dumping within the meaning of the Convention on the 
Prevention of
  ne Pollution by Dumping of Wastes and Other Matter signed in
London on
  ovember 1972; or
  any release directly arising from the exploration, 
exploitation and
  ciated off-shore processing of sea-bed mineral resources; or
  any release for the purposes of legitimate scientific research 
into
  ution abatement or control;
  g Kong ship" means--
  a ship registered in Hong Kong; and
  a vessel required to be licensed under Part IV of the Shipping 
and
  Control Ordinance (Cap. 313);
  " means oil of any description and includes spirit produced from 
oil
  ny description and also includes coal tar;
  p" means a vessel of any type whatsoever operating in the 
marine
  ronment and includes a hydrofoil, hovercraft, submersible or 
floating
  t and a fixed or floating platform.
 PART II REGULATIONS FOR THE PREVENTION AND CONTROL OF POLLUTION
  
  egulations for the prevention and control of pollution
  In this section--
  vention" means the International Convention for the 
Prevention of
  ution from Ships (including its protocols, annexes and 
appendices)
  h constitutes Attachment 1 to the Final Act of the 
International
  erence on Marine Pollution signed in London on 2 November 
1973, as
  fied by any international agreement referred to in subsection (2)
(b)
  );
  tocol" means the Protocol (including the annex thereto) 
relating to
  Convention which constitutes Attachment 2 to the Final Act 
of the
  rnational Conference on Tanker Safety and Pollution Prevention 
signed
  ondon on 17 February 1978, as modified by any international 
agreement
  rred to in subsection (2) (b) (iii); "substance other 
than oil"
  udes sewage and garbage of any kind.
  The Governor in Council may make regulations--
  relating to the prevention or control of pollution of the sea or
other
  rs by oil, or any substance other than oil, from ships; and
  for giving effect to--
  the Convention;
  the Protocol; and
  ) any other international agreement (whether made by 
resolution or
  rwise) which relates to the prevention or control of pollution
of the
  or other waters by oil, or any substance other than oil, from 
ships
  which applies to Hong Kong, including any agreement which
modifies any
  r such agreement.
  Regulations made under this section may be expressed to apply--
  to Hong Kong ships, wherever they may be; and
  to other ships while they are within the waters of Hong Kong.
  
  Regulations made under this section may provide that the 
regulations,
  ny provisions thereof, shall come into force on a date 
specified in
  regulations which is earlier than the date on which the 
international
  ement to which the regulations relate comes into force.
  Without limiting the generality of subsection (2), 
regulations made
  r this section may include provisions--
  for the approval of documents, the appointment of 
surveyors, the
  ying out of surveys and inspections and the rendering 
of other
  ices for the purposes of the regulations, whether in Hong 
Kong or
  where, and for the issue, duration, effect and 
recognition of
  ificates for those purposes;
  for the keeping, carriage and inspection of record books and 
other
  rds of operations involving oil, or any substance other than oil, 
on
  d ships;
  for the prohibition, regulation and control of the 
loading and
  iage on board ships, and the unloading or discharge from ships,
of oil
  ny substance other than oil and for procedures relating thereto;
  for the design and construction of, and the equipment and fittings 
on
  d, ships carrying oil or any substance other than oil;
  for the compulsory reporting of incidents involving pollution 
or the
  at of pollution for the purpose of giving effect to Protocol I
  visions concerning reports on incidents involving harmful 
substances)
  he Convention;
  for the payment of fees (whether prescribed under this Ordinance, 
the
  hant Shipping Ordinance (Cap. 281) or otherwise) in respect 
of any
  ey, inspection, certificate, service or other matter provided 
for by
  regulations;
  that contraventions of the regulations shall be offences
punishable by
  lties not exceeding--
  on conviction upon indictment, a fine of $5,000,000 and, in the 
case
  n individual, imprisonment for 2 years;
  on summary conviction, a fine of $500,000;
  that in the case of any such contravention an offence is committed
by-
  the master and the owner of the ship concerned; and
  where the contravention is due to the act or omission of 
another
  on, that person;
  for denying entry of any ship to the waters of Hong Kong in respect
of
  h any such contravention is believed to have occurred;
  for detaining any ship in respect of which any such 
contravention is
  eved to have occurred and for notifying the relevant consular
officer
  any) of the detention and of any proceedings against the ship;
and
  for the admission of prescribed or specified documents and 
certified
  es of documents as evidence in legal proceedings,
  the regulations may--
  make different provisions for different circumstances or in 
relation
  ifferent classes or descriptions of ships;
  provide for exemptions from any provisions of the 
regulations in
  ect of different classes or descriptions of ships;
  ) provide for the granting by the Director, on such terms (if any) 
as
  ay specify, of exemptions from any provisions of the 
regulations in
  ect of any ship, or class or description of ships, and 
for the
  ration or cancellation of any such exemption;
  provide for the approval by the Director of equivalent 
fittings,
  pment or procedures as alternatives to those prescribed;
  provide for the delegation of powers exercisable and 
functions
  ormable by virtue of the regulations;
  provide for the application of the regulations to the Crown; and
  ) include such incidental, supplemental and transitional
provisions as
  ar to the Governor in Council to be expedient for the purposes
of the
  lations.
  
  Any fees prescribed under this Ordinance--
  may be fixed at levels which provide for the recovery of 
expenditure
  rred or likely to be incurred by the Government or other authority 
in
  tion generally to the administration, regulation and control of 
Hong
  ships and of ports, ships and navigation in the waters of Hong 
Kong,
  shall not be limited by reference to the amount of 
administrative or
  r costs incurred or likely to be incurred in the provision 
of any
  icular service, facility or matter; and
  may, without prejudice to the generality of paragraph (a), be
fixed at
  erent amounts in relation to different sizes of ship, whether
measured
  onnage, length or otherwise, or in relation to different 
classes,
  s or descriptions of service, facility or ship.
  
  enalty for taking detained ship to sea
  Where a ship is authorized or ordered to be detained under
regulations
  under this Part, and after such detention or after service on 
the
  er of any notice of or order for such detention, the ship proceeds 
or
  mpts to proceed to sea before having been released by a 
competent
  ority, the master of the ship commits an offence and is liable 
to a
  of $500,000 and to imprisonment for 2 years; and if the 
owner or
  t or any person who sends the ship to sea is party or privy to 
the
  nce he also commits an offence and is liable to the same
punishment.
  Where a ship proceeds to sea in contravention of subsection (1)
whilst
  ng on board a public officer who is acting in the execution of 
his
  , the master and owner of the ship--
  in addition to any punishment to which they may be liable 
under
  ection (1), both commit an offence against this subsection 
and are
  liable to imprisonment for 6 months and to a fine of $20,000 and 
an
  tional fine of $1,000 for each day during the period from the date 
on
  h the ship proceeded to sea until the date on which the 
officer
  rns to Hong Kong or, if he does not return directly to Hong 
Kong,
  d have returned if he had travelled by the quickest practicable
route;
  
  are jointly and severally liable to pay to the Government all
expenses
  dental to the taking of the officer to sea and to securing his 
return
  ong Kong.
  Expenses referred to in subsection (2) (b) may be recovered as
if they
  a fine imposed by a magistrate.
 PART III SHIPPING CASUALTIES INVOLVING A RISK OF POLLUTION
  
  pplication of Part III
  Subject to subsections (2) and (3), this Part shall apply in 
relation
  ll ships whether within or outside the waters of Hong Kong.
  As respects a ship which--
  is not a Hong Kong ship; and
  is for the time being outside the waters of Hong Kong,
  power conferred on the governor by section 6 (2) to give 
directions
  only be exercised in relation to--
  an individual who is a British citizen, a British 
Dependent
  itories citizen, a British Overseas citizen or who under the Hong
Kong
  tish Nationality) Order 1986 (App. III, p. EG1) is a British
National
  rseas); or
  a body corporate which is established under the laws of Hong 
Kong,
  section 8 (2) shall apply to such an individual or body 
corporate
  .
  No direction under section 6 (2) shall apply to any vessel 
of Her
  sty's navy or to any ship not forming part of Her Majesty's navy
which
  ngs to Her Majesty or is held by any person on behalf of or for 
the
  fit of the Crown in right of Her Majesty's Government in the 
United
  dom or Her Majesty's Government in Hong Kong, and no action shall 
be
  n under section 6 (4) or (5) as respects any such vessel or ship.
  
  hipping casualties
  The powers conferred by this section may be exercised where--
  an accident has occurred to or in a ship; and
  in the opinion of the Governor--
  oil, or any substance other than oil, from the ship will or may 
cause
  ution on a large scale in Hong Kong or in the waters of Hong Kong;
  if the ship is one referred to in section 5 (2), the 
danger of
  ution is grave and imminent; and
  ) the exercise of the powers conferred by this section is 
urgently
  ed.
  For the purpose of preventing or reducing pollution, or the 
risk of
  ution, the Governor may give directions as respects the ship or 
its
  o--
  to the owner of the ship, or to any person in possession or control
of
  ship; or
  to the master of the ship; or
  to any salvor in possession of the ship, or to any person who is 
the
  ant or agent of any such salvor, and who is in charge of the 
relevant
  age operation.
  Directions under subsection (2) may require the person to whom 
they
  given to take, or refrain from taking, any action of 
any kind
  soever, and without limiting the generality of the 
foregoing the
  ctions may require--
  that the ship is to be, or is not to be, moved--
  to or from a specified place, area or locality;
  over a specified route; or
  that any oil or other cargo is to be, or is not to be, unloaded 
or
  harged; or
  that specified salvage measures are to be, or are not to be, taken.
  If in the opinion of the Governor the powers conferred by
subsection
  are, or have proved to be, inadequate for the purpose, the 
Governor
  for the purpose of preventing or reducing pollution, or the risk 
of
  ution, take, as respects the ship or its cargo, any action of any
kind
  soever, and without limiting the generality of the 
foregoing the
  rnor may--
  do anything he has power to require to be done by a direction 
under
  ection (2);
  cause operations to be undertaken for the sinking or 
destruction of
  ship, or any part of it, of a kind which is not within the means 
of
  person to whom he may give such a direction;
  cause operations to be undertaken which involve taking over
control of
  ship.
  The powers of the Governor under subsection (4) may also be 
exercised
  uch persons as may be authorized in that behalf by the Governor.
  A person concerned in complying with directions given, or in 
action
  n, under this section shall use his best endeavours to avoid risk 
to
  n life.
  Nothing in this section shall derogate from or affect any 
right or
  r of the Government existing apart from this section whether 
under
  rnational law or otherwise.
  
  Any action taken as respects a ship which is under arrest 
or as
  ects the cargo of such a ship, being action taken under a 
direction
  n under subsection (2), or under subsection (4) or (5)--
  does not constitute contempt of court; and
  shall not constitute a ground or cause of action in legal 
proceedings
  ituted against the Government.
  In this section--
  ident" includes the loss, stranding, abandonment of or damage 
to a
  ; "any substance other than oil" means--
  any substance specified in an order made under subsection (10);
and
  any other substance which is liable to create a hazard to 
human
  th, to harm living resources and marine life, to damage 
amenities or
  nterfere with other legitimate uses of the sea;
  cified", in relation to a direction under subsection (2), 
means
  ified in the direction.
  The Governor may, by order published in the Gazette, 
specify any
  tance for the purposes of the definition of "any substance other 
than
  in subsection (9).
  
  irections; right to recover in respect of unreasonable loss or
damage
  If any action taken under a direction under section 6 (2), or 
under
  ion 6 (4) or (5)--
  was not reasonably necessary to prevent or reduce pollution or,
as may
  ppropriate, the risk of pollution; or
  was such that the good it did or was  likely  to 
do  was
  roportionately less than the expense incurred, or damage suffered, 
as
  sult of the action,
  rson incurring expense or suffering damage as a result of the 
action,
  f himself having taken the action, shall be entitled to 
claim and
  ver compensation from the Government.
  In determining whether subsection (1) applies in a particular 
case,
  unt shall be taken of--
  the extent and risk of pollution if the action had not been taken;
  the likelihood of the action being effective; and
  the extent of the damage which has been caused by the action.
  Any reference in this section to the taking of any action 
includes a
  rence to a compliance with a direction not to take some 
specified
  on.
  ffences in relation to section 6
  A person to whom a direction is given under section 6 (2) who fails
to
  ly with any requirement of the direction, commits an offence.
  A person who wilfully obstructs any person who is--
  acting on behalf of the Governor in connection with the 
giving or
  ice of a direction under section 6 (2);
  acting in compliance with such a direction; or
  acting under subsection (4) or (5) of that section,
  its an offence.
  In proceedings for an offence under subsection (1), it shall 
be a
  nce for the accused to prove that--
  he used all due diligence to secure compliance with the direction;
or
  he had reasonable cause for believing that such compliance would 
have
  lved a serious risk to human life.
  A person who commits an offence under this section is liable-
-
  on conviction upon indictment, to a fine of $5,000,000;
  on summary conviction, to a fine of $500,000.
  ervice of directions under section 6
  If the Governor is satisfied that a company or other body
corporate is
  one to which section 338 or 356 of the Companies Ordinance (Cap. 
32)
  ies so as to authorize the service of a direction on that body 
under
  er of those sections, he may give a direction under section 6 (2)--
  to that body, as the owner of, or the person in possession or 
control
  a ship, by serving the direction on the master of the ship; or
  to that body, as a salvor, by serving the direction on the person 
in
  ge of the salvage operations.
  For the purpose of giving or serving a direction under section 
6 (2)
  r on any person on a ship, a person acting on behalf of the 
Governor
  l have the right to go on board the ship.
  
  Enforcement of fines
  e a fine imposed in proceedings against the owner or master of
a ship
  an offence under this Part is not paid at the time ordered by 

不分页显示   总共2页  1 [2]

  下一页